1994 issue 4

Back

Volume 3, issue 4

Editorial

Coercion in psychiatry – viewpoints

PIOTR BARANOWSKI1, JANUSZ MORASIEWICZ1, MARIA JAŃSKA-SKOMOROWSKA1, MONIKA KANTORSKA1, MONIKA SZCZYRBOWSKA1
1. Katedra i Klinika Psychiatrii Akademii Medycznej we Wrocławiu
Postępy Psychiatrii i Neurologii, 1994, 3, 497-510
Keywords: coercion in psychiatry, statutory legal regulations, patients’ opinions, medical staff opinions, medical students’ opinions

Abstract

Views on coercion in psychiatry as expressed by medical staff of mental hospitals, psychiatric patients, and senior medical students are compared in the paper. These data were obtained using a questionnaire based on the draft of the Mental Health Act of May 1993. Ss' responses were analyzed for their concordance with the Act provisions, and a number of respondent categories were singled out: those holding liberal or radical views, and others, preferring the medical or legal-administrative models of psychiatric care. A marked concordance of opinions was found in all groups under study, as well as medicalization of attitudes, and the need for extending recommendations for the use of coercion in psychiatry beyond the limits proposed in the Act.

Address for correspondence:
Dr Piotr Baranowski,
Katedra i Klinika Psychiatrii AM,
ul. Kraszewskiego 25,
50-229 Wrocław